Phil,
Attempting to find successs in music is like the "Gold Mining' days of the 1800's in California and Alaska. There were a ton of people who actually went out there and dug, panned, wandered, etc. Very few succeeded, but NO ONE who stayed at home got anything unless they were investors in the Gold mining conglomorates. And even those people had a lot of losses and bogus claims. The real investors visited their investments.
When I read all these forums online, NSAI sites, etc. it is like watching those commercials for PUBLISHER'S CLEARING HOUSE. "You may have already won cash or prizes!" Riiiiigggghhhttttt!!!!" And some monkey's might fly out of my butt.
Coming from the real world of music, I really don';t quite know where all this got started. Well I do,but like to plead ignorance. There has always been a "you can get rich' componant in the entertainment business. There were always those ads in the backs of newspapers and magazines, "Set your poems to music..." If you have a readership of 100,000 people, and can get 10% (ten thousand) to send in $5-$20 bucks, you are going to do pretty well.
CONTESTS are the same, they offer prizes, guitars, studio sessions, trips to Nashville, etc. If you are a music store, contribute a cheap guitar that cost you $100, and it gets 5000 people to know your name,it is pretty worth it. Even when they are great prizes, say a Taylor or Gibson guitar, this are BILLION DOLLAR COMPANIES, think they are going to miss a $400 item?
I was even a PRIZE in a couple of contests. I donated my tours to people and did a few of them. More people heard of me and I got some paying ones out of those.
So the cottage industry sprung up of song plugger, publishing, mentoring, (such as myself), former hit writers giving songwriting lessons and critiques, NSAI, Songwriter's Guild, college courses, you name it. Just like the merchants who sold picks and shovels to the people going into the mountains after those miner claims. Did the miner's need them? Yep. Ain't going to dig anything without a shovel, or pan without a pan. And having those items on the wagon train or train out west were not possible. So they were essential services.
The current crop of services are of varying degrees of success. Are they rip offs? Not nessasarily. Lets just say they are overpromising and underdelivering.
What I do works because it is very specific. I don't offer deals, money, or chances to buy a lottery ticket. I show the craft, the networking, the work behind the scenes, the reality of chances, and how to up the level of your odds. Want to get on a golf green and NOT lose every ball in your bag? Get some golf lessons, and at least get close to par. But that doesn't mean you are going to play with Tiger at the Masters. These days Tiger isn't even playing the Masters.
The "get rich quick" stuff gets everyone. The entire "downloading music" industry is another one. Spotify, Pandora, Napster and whatever today's fad of the minute are out there promoting music. There are millions and millions of people out there and millions and millions of songs trying to get to them. Eveyrone puts their stuff out there and some get hits, but none really do with out some kind of "REAL" presence.
I was seeing a forum the other day about the latest newcomer, talking about getting his music out there on the Internet. He was excited he had gotten about a dozen "likes" (Why I hate that stuff so much!) and he thought he was on his way. He was about to hire a radio promoter. That is about $10,000 he could just as easily flush down the comode. BECAUSE HE IS NOT A PERFORMING ARTIST!!!! You can get on every web site in the world and even radio podcasting, etc. What is it going to do if you are not OUT THERE DOING IT? Nothing.
But people have gotten so accustomed to getting things through the Internet, they think they can just "put something out there" and things will magically start happening. Yes, you may have one valuable prizes. "Insert another thousand dollars per minute please!"
Finding like minded writers in your area is the same thing. If you just go to a few open mics, it is going to be hard. Open mics are the amateur nights. Anyone can show up. Anyone who gets up there and does their bad poetry reading. Who does the latest Miley Cyrus or weird singer song. The one who gets up and does the song that noit only makes no sense, but is fairly uncomfortable to listen to because it is dark depressing, has no central melody, has nothing about it that does anything but make you feel sorry for the supposed writer.
Those are called "OPEN MICS" because they are OPEN for anyone to get on the MICROPHONE.
What you are going to have to do is graduate up to the WRITERS NIGHT. How you do that is first get with your two or three other people who are interested in doing something, and having a regular show that people can participate in. but it has to be run like a SHOW. IF YOU DO IT, THEY WILL COME!!! Trust me! There are probably writers and performers all over the place. But you have to give them some reason to show up. Or keep looking till you find more performers.
If there is a college around there, go near the campus. Go to the coffee shops where the students hang out. Go tot he bullitien boards. There will be notices there for jams, open stages AND WRITERS NIGHTS going on.
They ARE THERE!!!! I promise you!
Matt Casey and Tony M. thought there were no one around their areas in New Hampshire and Boston too. Tony started a hugely successful writers show and had myself and a few other hit writers from Nashville. he was having capacity crowds and started doing workshops. I was there on a Saturday when thirty people showed up for the workshop.They all said "There is nothing going on in the area." I went to the local entertainment paper and found NINTEEN writers nights, open mics and open stages within a 20 minute driving area.
Julie Moriva was in Crivitz Wisconsin, an hour away from Green Bay. She ended up with 60 writers in her NSAI group. She ended up with a writing deal with Taylor Swift's Big Machine" publishing. There was "no one around her" either.
Matt Casey said there was no one around him either. Next week he has 30 performers on a New England to Nashville show. He has four hit writer coming there for a workshop on Martha's Vinyard. He has about 200 writers in his Facebook group, and now has started his own publishing company. Matt has about two dozen writers he works with regularly.
Phil, I have done workshops in Gainsville, Tallahassee, Daytona, Ft. Lauderdale, Miami, Panama City, Destin, Orlando (Twice), and of course the FRANK BROWN FESTIVAL. They are there, trust me.
But you have to go MINE for the one's who stand out. Most writers and artists are solo and don't want anything to do with anybody else. Those are your internet artists. Anyone you talk to or read about that is ONLY an Internet artist or entity is SPAM EMAIL. Period. No one knows, them, no one has time to find them and they frankly are only interested in having someone ELSE LISTEN TO THEM. They are not interacting, not trying. They have their heads in their derriare.
Sunday I was at the songwriters showcase in Kalamazoo Michigan. I had gone up to see Dani Jamerson and Shelagh Brown perform and to do the anniversery of the CHILI PEPPERS writers group. Another one that was formed because "no one was around." The show is held in Plainwell, Michigan, about 30 minutes from downtown Kalamazoo. It is in the middle of farmland. This is quite literally the MIDDLE OF NOWHERE! About forty writers, artists, interested parties, relatives, all showed up. I did an hour "conversation with writers" and we all did a three hour show with the CHILI PEPPERS being the lead round.
Around three songs from the end of my set, this guy and his wife show up. He is about sixty,and I have actually seen him there before. He sat down, talked to his wife while I performed and basically was thinking he was in his living room. He also was sitting in the first row. After I finished and we got a standing ovation, people wanting to take pictures, get autographs, buy CD's, this guy pulls me over. He wanted to know what he could do with his "funny songs." Wanted to know if he could "send them to me so I could do something with them." Now this was exactly the same conversation I had with him two year ago. He is a "NUSCANCE WRITER." That is about 70% and those are the worst of all. I don't have to listen to his songs because I know they are politically incorrect, insulting, nonsensical, written from a style of the 1970's (he is about 60 years old) and most of all UNFUNNY.
I offered to give him your and OD's phone numbers.
This what this is. You have to search for things that work with you. Period.
And yes, Phil, I do kind of sober the reality up and tell the truth. But you know what? There is a guy out there on the road,playing major concerts all over the country named Frankie Ballard, who was once out there around nobody too. Dani Jamerson is in the wings, RiDawn Rae, Jarod Nichols, there are people out there starting this run.
Members of those writers groups connected with artists and got in on the ground floors. It can be done. But you have to write what they want to say and write with them.
So the choice is always very simple. Do you want to spend money you can't afford on song pluggers, or you want to actually do this? Or just do it in your own living room?
Choice is yours.
MAB