Kevin. yesterday Eddie Minyard, who is on my friends list, and has been invited to my private rom, was able to listen to at least one song there and comment on it. As of today, I have invited you, OD, Justin, and Eddie to my private page. I have kept it to just you few only because I don't really understand how it is supposed to work. Eddie really is working hard on the feature to get the kinks out.
John, to answer your question about a peer-to-peer forum (since I'm the one who brought it up); It's a hard call. On the old site, very few folks used it. Most folks posted lyrics only in the Writers Room, and put their "finished" song in open mic. It appears the same thing is happening here. I'm not sure why folks join this site? But I'm starting to think it is to simply, "Get their music out there". I set up an account on SoundCloud and ReverbNation, but only because I was using the peer-to-peer forum on the NSAI site, and they don't have anywhere to upload songs. I love the fact there is a place here to upload songs, and I will probably use the Private Room to upload songs I want critiques on.
phil g.